2012-04-04

Interpersonal Communication

Today, I'd like to take a look at interpersonal communication. Namely, I would ask you to think about controversial issues on which you disagree with someone. For the sake of argument, let us suppose that you are actually interested in talking to someone about the issue. And, further for the sake of argument, let us suppose that by "talking" I mean actually carrying on an open, good-faith conversation.

For such a conversation to take place, you and your conversation partner would need to meet a few basic requirements. (1) You would have to speak the same language. (2) You would have to agree on the same basic definitions of words. (Believe it or not, points (1) and (2) are not necessarily always both true.) (3) You would have to have the communicative means to facilitate the discussion; in other words, you would either have to be in the same room, or have access to a phone, email, Skype, whatever.

We can assemble a good, reasonable list of such requirements, but one of them is not immediately obvious. That is, You would both have to be capable of understanding each other. You might be tempted to assume that if two people speak the same language and agree on the same definitions of words, then the two of you must certainly be capable of understanding each other.

Not so, for reasons outlined recently by Lubos Motl. Regarding that recent viral video of a woman who apparently did not understand the concept of miles per hour, Motl writes:
But if someone asks how long does it take to go 80 miles if your speed is 80 miles per hour, you must combine a huge number of words, something like 17 words, and the interrelationships between all of them matter. Since the blonde doesn't have enough memory in her CPU – one needs at least 100 bytes to do so – she just tears the complicated sentence to pieces and starts to instinctively reply to the pieces.
 Motl goes on to express the following wisdom, in his inimitable and politically incorrect way:
Of course, even if the blondes could remember the whole sentence – 17 words or so – they would probably lack the functions in their CPUs that are needed to convert the words into the actual information and reprocess the information so that it is replaced by an equivalent information, and so on. Math is tough and thinking is hard, especially if you need to design and manage your thinking and algorithms yourself. That's why we may see that by their proclamations, these women articulate lots of misinterpretations of the propositions they have heard. For example, if you say that it takes 1 hour to drive 80 miles if you drive 80 miles per hour, some of them believe that you are also automatically saying that your speed is 1 mile per minute regardless of your speed :-), especially because an hour has 80 minutes and a mile is the same thing as a minute, which is exactly what she wanted to disprove. Well, you're not saying anything of the sort but with the limited resolution of the blondes, they may think they are. It's because you are saying that "the problem is easy" and their misinterpretation is the only way how they can imagine that things could be easy; they're actually not able or willing to remember and process the thing that you are actually telling them.
An even more irreverent story I heard came from my mother, who told me one time long ago that some people believe it is impossible for two people to carry on a conversation if there is a 12-point difference in IQ between them. I won't comment on the validity of such a claim, I merely present it as a theory held by some.

Nevertheless, I believe Motl's core analysis is a true one. I think that certain topics are very complicated, and that not all of us are well-enough-equipped with the tools of ratiocination to be able to process all of the various nuances and form them into a single essence.

Now, in some cases the "problem" with your conversation partner is not that the person lacks sufficient computational power. Rather, in many cases, the other person simply refuses to consider all of the factors involved in the conversation.

For example, an advocate of socialized medicine is not prone to considering the economic detriments of tax increases, because such a person has already previously concluded that rich people should be charged more money than they currently are. Therefore, while the economic impacts of tax burdens are objective facts, they are not important facts, according to those people who wish to exclude such things from the conversation.

So there are two factors at play: The inability to compute all of the information involved, and the unwillingness to compute all of the information, even if it can be computed.

These two factors are - in my opinion - the two most important obstacles when it comes to interpersonal communication. Overcoming them requires both patience and good faith. When it comes to controversial topics, both patience and good faith tend to be in very short supply.

And that, friends, is why controversies remain controversies and arguing about controversial things with people who flat-out disagree with you is a futile endeavor.

2012-04-03

The Myth of the Socialist Paradise

One of the most persistent myths out there is that various socialist countries are doing things perfectly, that their citizens basic needs are completely provided for by their socialist governments and that they have learned to create socialist perfection within their borders. This is stated to be some kind of governmental ideal.

This is patently untrue. Leftists often tout Scandinavia as being just such a socialist utopia, but as we will see in a moment, this is complete rubbish.

First, take a look at this CBC news story about the United Nations' global happiness ratings. I haven't investigated the quality of the study itself, but similar stories are rather regularly published by the CBC and other news organizations. Here is a taste of their spin on the idea (emphases added):
Canada placed fifth in the first World Happiness Report, an attempt to measure social and economic well-being around the world that was tabled during a special conference at the UN on Monday. And if there was one surprise in the document it might be this: a nation's happiness is not necessarily tied to its economy...
And, later:
"A number of recent studies have shown that, in many developed countries, including Japan, happiness is not proportional to economic wealth," Nakano said. "This finding, often called the 'paradox of happiness,' has given rise to international discussion on how to enhance individual well-being through government policies." 
The report also listed a number of practical suggestions for governments to promote happiness among their citizens, including helping people meet their basic needs, reinforcing social systems, implementing active labour policies, improving mental health services, promoting compassion, altruism and honesty, and helping the public resist hyper-commercialism.
Surprise, surprise: virtually the totality of the socialist agenda is promoted as a "helpful suggestion" to improve the happiness of citizens.

Of course, I have been following this concept for a little while, and noticed this passage immediately:
Bhutan, the tiny Himalayan nation that tops Asia in the report, convened Monday's meeting seeking to develop a new economic model based on principles of happiness and well being. Prime Minister Jigmi Y. Thinley told the conference a new model is vital if mankind is to avoid its current unsustainable and self-destructive course.
This should surprise no one, since Bhutan's King coined the term "Gross Domestic Happiness" in the first place and immediately used it to promote his political legacy as some sort of politically palatable alternative to liberalization. In its weakest form, GDH means "money can't buy you happiness." More often, it's a way to disparage the profit-driven facts of life that exist any time capitalism is allowed to flourish.

But anyway, I was talking about how socialist paradises are a myth. Here's what I mean. The following are the five countries that top the list of the "happiest countries in the world," according to this most recent study. In parentheses beside the name of each country, I have included their rank on the Economic Freedom Index.
  1. Denmark (11)
  2. Norway (40)
  3. Finland (17)
  4. Netherlands (15)
  5. Canada (6)
And, by comparison, the "bottom four" least-happiest countries and their corresponding ranking on the EFI:
  • Togo (155)
  • Benin (118)
  • Central African Republic (145)
  • Sierra Leone (152)
Contorting these results into the bizarre conclusion that wealth and economic freedom has scant impact on the comparative happiness of a country's citizens is a pretty egregious lie.

It is also a patently ridiculous belief. As much as some leftists would love to suggest that socialism is a panacea of communal happiness, the data actually provides strong evidence to the contrary. Like it or not, Scandinavian countries are among the most capitalistic countries in the world.

UPDATE:
I'm not content to just leave it at that. Here is a plot of all the countries that appear on both lists. The x-axis is the "happiness" ranking, and the y-axis is the freedom ranking. The trendline was added for the reader's benefit.


Righteous Indignation

Righteous indignation strikes me as being a very powerful force. It seems to possess an almost supernatural ability to change the behavior of susceptible people. And, in fact, most people appear to be susceptible to righteous indignation.

There are probably evolutionary reasons why righteous indignation has developed as a force within the social dynamic.But if you're a faithful Stationary Waves reader, then you already understand that I don't really enjoy looking at human behavior through the lens of evolutionary mechanisms. After all, when one becomes indignant, he is not aiming at any evolutionary purpose; he is not guaranteeing the success of his progeny. He is simply trying to get his way.

In my view, righteous indignation is more like a childhood temper tantrum. When a toddler doesn't get his way, he is quick to proclaim that the situation isn't fair, that people don't love him, that others have previously received the benefits that he himself is asking for now. The more resistance the toddler faces, the more indignant he becomes, right up to the point where he collapses on the ground, screaming and crying, in a last-ditch effort to evoke capitulation in others.

Naturally, temper tantrums only work on very weak parents. Then, why does righteous indignation seem to work on almost anybody?

Tyler Cowen and India
Here's a case in point. Last night, Tyler Cowen posted a movie review of the new movie Mirror, Mirror on his blog, Marginal Revolution. At first, I thought it was just another one of Cowen's movie reviews, but the commenters on the website knew better. First, I noticed this from someone calling himself "TrollsWillTroll":
Tyler gets bullied.
Tyler appeases bully.
Tyler sets precedent.
Curious as to what the context of this comment was, I read through the comments sections of the last few MR posts, and quickly found what I was looking for. On March 31st, Cowen posted one of his multiplicitous "Assorted links" posts, in which he provides bullet-point links with little or no follow-up commentary (the commentary is supposed to be provided by the readers. There, Cowen simply stated: "5. The rising hostility to foreign firms in India, worrying."

Pretty innocuous, and yet a character calling himself "Sandeep" went on a rather astounding flurry of righteous indignation, beginning with this:

#5 was not meant for analysis. TC posts such links only because he wants to trash a country that he believes is populated with subhumans. 
I say this because there has been an unmistakeably consistent pattern that: 1. While most links from TC about other countries contain both good and bad things (in some cases only good), India is the only country about which his writing has been almost exclusively negative (the remaining instances being neutral). 2. Usually defects in societies invites analysis at MR; but in the case of India, TC’s links NEVER goes into historical factors. Those articles only involve elaborate descriptions of how things suck in India. 
In contrast he has written positive things about Pakistan, posted a link claiming there was brain surgery in Turkey 5000 years ago etc.
It's difficult to take this sort of thing seriously, and the majority of MR commenters certainly did not. Cowen, however, did, and posted a comment of his own - albeit not as a "reply" to anyone in particular: "India is one of my very favorite countries and I wish to go back soon for a third visit!"

Combine that "appeasement" with the overly analytical movie review of Mirror, Mirror, and it would appear that "TrollsWillTroll" was exactly right about Cowen, at least in this case.

Ryan at a Panel Discussion
A few years ago, I attended a public panel discussion, the topic of which was a very controversial and highly visible international political issue. (For the sake of my example, the particular topic in question is unimportant.)

During the first half of the discussion, people were civil, mild-mannered, and engaged in good-faith, open, honest dialogue. The panel discussion was achieving its aim.

Then, suddenly, a woman in the audience stood up to "ask a question," and instead... yep, you guessed it. She became indignant, righteously indignant. She took offense to the whole topic as an affront to herself and her culture. She rambled on and on. Then, to my surprise, she continued rambling as she picked up her coat, kept scolding the panel, and continued this way as she walked right out the door.

It would have been hilarious, had it not completely changed the group dynamic. Something about her righteous indignation had sent a social cue throughout the entire audience. Suddenly, all good faith was lost. Suddenly, real open dialogue was impossible. People stopped making points. Instead, they began clinging to the most extreme versions of their points of view.

The discussion evaporated. The panel wrapped up, and we all went home, somewhat dumber than we were when we arrived.

Ryan In School
One of my favorite stories to tell people is the one about the time I was sitting in a high school civics class, discussing the multiple facets of the abortion issue. The first day we tackled the issue in class, nearly everyone there was open-minded and curious about things. When the teacher solicited everyone's opinion, the students gave cautious, balanced statements that conveyed the fact that they were simply unsure about these things. They were high school students. It was a normal reaction.

Yet, when we returned to class the next day, I suddenly discovered that my classmates had magically become polarized on the issue. I presume that they had returned home the previous evening and discussed it with their parents, whose views of abortion were much more solidified than those of their children. And what debate inspires more righteous indignation from people than the debate around abortion?

It is certainly conjecture on my part, but I think it nonetheless a reasonable inference to suggest that these poor, confused teenagers had tried to discuss a complicated issue with their parents that night, only to face their parents' righteous indignation on the issue. The impact of this on the children was to make their views - the children's views - more polarized.

After a single evening, they had completely altered their approach to the issue from being one of cautious open-mindedness to one of complete and polarized closure.

A couple of my regular readers were in that class. I hope they remember it, too. It was a formative couple of days in my life.

The Magic Power of Righteous Indignation
What is it about this force that inspires such complete capitulation in social groups. Why is that one indignant person can change the dynamic of an entire social group from being open-minded to being close-minded?

For those of you familiar with passionate religious groups, I am sure you will agree that they are another classic example. A group of believers can be as moderate as they please, up until the point that one of them starts pointing out all the sin in the room; suddenly, everyone becomes the most pious religious adherent ever seen. (I have witnessed this happening among people of virtually every major religion in the world.)

How many political negotiations have been completely undone by righteous indignation? How many governmental compromises have been negated by one or more sides becoming thoroughly indignant, throwing the political equivalent of a fit, and polarizing their views?

I would never suggest that every compromise is a good one, but certainly good compromises do exist, and many of them have been destroyed by indignant reactionaries. You may fill in the blanks with your specific examples, if you wish.

The fact remains that what would be a temper tantrum in a small child suddenly becomes black magic in the hands of socially connected adult. Admonishing the broader group for their wrong-headedness and unfairness, an indignant person can alter the course of that and all future discussions within the group.

It is like clockwork. Two people can be having a good, positive, and open discussion, but if a third chimes in with indignation, at least one of the first two parties will end up siding with the third. The issue is irrelevant. The only relevant fact is that there exists righteous indignation in the room. Righteous indignation always wins.

So What Do We Do About It?
I am probably not the best person to provide a way forward when it comes to these situations. For one thing, I consider indignation to be some variant of a childish temper tantrum. Put another way, righteous indignation is powerless against me. I don't take it seriously. I consider it a major shortcoming of those who exhibit it.

For another thing, I have never been in a discussion in which righteous indignation was overcome by the group. It has absolutely poisoned each and every discussion it has touched, as far as my own experience is concerned. This is true regardless of whether I have been an active participant in the discussion, or a mere passive observer.

Finally, the vast majority of people appear susceptible to it, as far as I can tell. So if others dislike it, you wouldn't know it from their propensity to console the indignant at every opportunity.

Therefore, as unhelpful as this suggestion may seem, my recommendation is to mostly steer clear of it. It is a good thing to foster positive, open discussions with other people. However, we must learn to accept that as soon as righteous indignation enters the room, all hope is lost. The discussion cannot continue. Our best hope is to wrap things up quickly before they get out of hand, and perhaps attempt another discussion at some later date, and hopefully without the person who became indignant the first time around.

This nasty, poisonous stuff called righteous indignation can only be avoided, because there is no winning when pitted against a person whose sole objective is to inspire others to feel sorry for him or her.

If reason and open-mindedness are the goals, you simply will not find them in the indignant.

2012-04-02

Omnipotent Government

Today you can find me over at The Ludwig von Mises Institute of Canada's blog, discussing the importance of Ludwig von Mises' classic Omnipotent Government. Here's the punchline:
Today, we live in a world embroiled in what Mises called “total war.” What else would you call it? The Middle East is overrun by warring chieftains and hegemonic world leaders seeking to carve their name into the desert rocks forever as the One Who Conquered. We posture, we levy sanctions, we conspire with oil and money supplies, we pit ourselves against each other in futile religious conflict. Above all, we die, we die, we die. 
How did we get here? Halfway through Omnipotent Government, I can say that Mises has left us a solid foundation of historical analysis, showing exactly how countries end up in predicaments like this, as well as a lonely warning against etatism, since – after all – free countries do not benefit from conquest.

2012-03-30

Pick a Freedom, Any Freedom

Courtesy FreeMagicLive.com
A short while ago, I discussed the problem with our general attitude toward liberty and politics; namely, that when all is said and done, it works out to be that on average, we oppose everything.

How might life be different if we were each to select one matter of liberty and make it our "calling card?" There are hundreds - if not thousands - of bizarre, confusing, detrimental, and/or discriminatory laws on the books. Any one of them would do.

Many of us might choose something highly visible, such as the right to marry. Some of us might choose something that is only relevant to a comparatively small number of people, such as a bylaw in Smiths Falls, Ontario that reportedly restricts the number of mentally disabled persons in group homes to 36 individuals in the entire town. Some of us might choose to capture the momentum gained on the Ontario Appeals Court's recent decision to decriminalize brothels, and take on other victimless crimes, while others might go against the grain and fight anti-cell phone laws.

We would probably never agree with each other completely about exactly which of these laws ought to be repealed first - or at all - but the impact of choosing just one cause for liberty that is important to you personally would have a spill-over effect on society that would be sweeping.

Imagine a world in which political discussion begins with, "We ought to re-think this law," as opposed to "There ought to be a law." Imagine a world in which the common thread of discussion was the many different ways we are restricted in our lives, and how those restrictions might be dissolved and our lives improved.

Imagine what it would be like if, rather than seeking out a political justification for a law or policy we just heard about, our knee-jerk reaction was to become extremely critical of any new law or policy unless we felt we had received adequate justification.

It might just mean that, on average, we want to be free.

Okay, I'll get the ball rolling: My pet issue is going to be the abolition of tariffs, quotas, and other such international trade restrictions. What will yours be?

2012-03-27

Nike+ = Awesome!

The Nike+ running website did not completely reveal itself to me until I "synced my run" by uploading data from my watch to the software. Once Nike+ had some data to analyze, it revealed all the many treasures accessible to a data-junkie like myself. Here's a quick run-down (no pun intended) of what's on the site for users:
  • GPS route map, of course
  • A total chart of speed across the full length of each run (speed on the y-axis, distance on the x-axis)
  • Miles per day, miles per week, miles per run, total miles, and so forth
  • Average pace, pace per each mile, each individual split time, etc.
  • Fastest-ever run (by pace), fastest 5K, fastest 10K
  • Longest run (by distance)
  • Miles by terrain, time of day, weather conditions, etc.
  • More things that I am leaving out
The site also gives you access to training programs developed by professional coaches (assuming you are not following mine), site-wide challenges, site-wide community events and so forth.

Suffice it to say, I am highly impressed. I do hope the rest of you will choose to join me (my username is StationaryWaves). This is going to be great fun!

Problem: Solution

We live in an increasingly consequentialist world.

Consequentialism is, broadly defined, the belief that the consequences of one's actions determine the degree to which one's consequences are ethical. Of course, long-time Stationary Waves readers know that I object to consequentialist ethics. My core objection is that while one may have good intentions, one's conduct en route may be highly morally questionable.

Think of a few examples that highlight my point:
  • The Count of Monte Cristo dedicated his whole life to revenge against a terrible wrong that was done to him and his true love. He kills and hurts a lot of people along the way.
  • In choosing to save a nation of people from a terrible dictator, the US government killed thousands of innocent victims.
  • A Wall Street executive is morally compelled to act in the best interests of his shareholders, because they have entrusted their interests to him. Along the way, he discovers that accepting a federal "bail-out" leaves his shareholders and his family in the best possible position. He therefore agrees to privatize gains and socialize losses.
Entrenched in the consequentialist viewpoint is the idea that the actor is better at assessing total utility than anyone else. Not only do I disagree with this viewpoint, I further believe that it is impossible for any one human being to evaluate utility for others.

Hence, while I think the spirit of consequentialism is good, the methodology is bad; and, ironically, consequentialism seems to lead to many bad consequences.

The Problem
Nevertheless, consequentialism is at the root of most policy these days. By "policy," I mean both new legislation at the federal, state, provincial, and local levels, as well as corporate policies, terms & conditions, legal contracts, and so on. I think consequentialism is a major source of conflict in the world today. People believe that as long as they're aiming for a good outcome, their actions are justified. If this is a person's core assumption, then there is potentially no limit to the bad behavior in which they are willing to engage.

Consider yesterday's report from the Associated Press, covering the cancellation of a community Easter Egg hunt due to "pushy parents."

Lenny Watkins, who lives a block away from Bancroft Park, took his friend's son, then 4, to the hunt in 2009. "I just remember having a wonderful time, him with his Easter basket," Watkins said, adding he can understand why a parent would step in. 
"You have all these eggs just lying around, and parents helping out. You better believe I'm going to help my kid get one of those eggs. I promised my kid an Easter egg hunt, and I'd want to give him an even edge." 
Jennifer Rexford, who used to live near the park, said she participated in public Easter egg hunts with her boys, ages 3, 8 and 14. She doesn't anymore, because of "pushy parents" that she said she has dealt with at the hunts. 
"It just seems to be the mindset. People just want the best for their kids," Rexford said.
To many of these parents, it simply doesn't matter whose children's Easter Egg hunt they ruin, because the ultimate consequence is a good one: "What's best for their kids."

As you can see, this isn't just an abstract problem, nor is it merely crass political yammering. The problems of consequentialism impact us all the time in ways we don't immediately understand if we're not well-versed in ethical theories.

The Solution
The Prisoner's Dilemma is the problem in Game Theory that describes two people's incentives to cheat against an agreement between them when they have a reason to believe that the other person might cheat.

In other words, if I have reason to believe that you're going to hop the fence and grab some Easter eggs for your kids, I have all the incentive I need to do the same. But please realize: in doing this, we might be ruining this Easter egg hunt along with all future hunts.

If we don't have it in us to craft a really good abstract argument against consequentialism and apply it to all future ethical problems we come across, then we might on the other hand need a simple, rational way of looking at these situations that is enough to make our knee-jerk consequentialism abate a little bit.

The Golden Rule is handy, but it's not enough. The temptation to cheat is too much.

Well, we'll never control the actions of other people. We'll never prevent them from cheating, taking, grabbing everything they can and ruining it for the rest of us. But we can change our own behavior. To that end, I'd like to make two humble suggestions as starting points for a solution to rampant consequentialism:
  1. Limit Your Exposure To Collectivism: While a city Easter egg hunt could be a fun community event, it is probably highly inadvisable to wed your child's Easter fun to that one event. If you want to participate in such things, go ahead. But plan some other activities with your children, too. In doing so, you replace a major disappointment with a minor one. You also teach your child a good lesson about the Tragedy of the Commons and the tendency people have to take all they can get. Taking this outside the context of a community event, don't submit too many aspects of your own personal happiness to the community at large. Don't couch your medical future on socialized medicine. Don't hang your notion of safety on foreign wars and airport security. Don't marry your concept of economic prosperity to the actions of governments or central banks. Live your own life, and take your licks.
  2. Practice Utility Temperance: Utility Temperance is what I call a person's ability to exercise restraint in the face of unabashed hedonism, simply for the sake of not being too decadent. A sweet-tooth might forego a second helping of cake, not because he'll "get fat," but because eating multiple pieces of chocolate cake is wholly unnecessary and decadent. This is a concept that ties into Virtue Ethics in that the restraint being practiced isn't practiced because the long-term outcome is bad, but rather simply because avoiding unabashed hedonism would simply, objectively be a bad thing. If you can take a step back from time to time and not simply hoard every scrap of tangible benefit you can get your paws on, you come to a point where you better appreciate the things you have. Put another way, sometimes turning off the stereo helps you appreciate the value of silence.
I'm not saying these two suggestions will solve all of our problems, but they are certainly a start. We don't want to clear-cut our moral forest. Hopefully you will find these ideas helpful the next time you face the darker side of consequentialism in your life.

2012-03-26

Keep Up With Stationary Waves Running

Today, I bought a new gadget: A Nike+ SportWatch GPS.

Those of you who have been following me on Facebook and Google+ already know about my new-found fondness for the website MapMyRun.com. There, you can map out your daily runs, keep track of your diet and nutrition, your personal statistics, and so forth.

Of course, it was only a matter of time before a company came along to pump all of these features through a single, unified channel. Nike+ purports to be that channel. (Granted, I believe Polar and Garmin both beat Nike to the punch here, but Nike is Nike, after all, a world leader in fitness and especially running. So I am placing my bets on Nike here.)

Here's how it works: I don the SportWatch GPS, tell it to start tracking me, and then it monitors my speed and distance via GPS. It comes with a little GPS sensor, which I attach to one of my shoes. (Nike, of course, sells shoes specifically designed for this purpose, but there are plenty of after-market harnesses for use with non-Nike running shoes.) It automatically maps my runs, it tracks my personal records, caloric expenditure, changes in elevation, etc. etc. It does all of this automatically, so no more beeping my watch all the time. From now on, all I have to do is start up the watch, and away I go.

If you don't feel like dropping coin on a fancy new running watch, you can always simply use your sensor in conjunction with your iPod nano and reap all the same benefits.

Of course, there is a social networking component to all of this, as well. Anyone can sign up for a Nike+ account and join in the global running community. I'm not big on global communities, but I am big on Stationary Waves.

Therefore, I'm inviting you all to sign up at Nike+ and add me as your running friend, username StationaryWaves (of course). If we can't meet up for a run in person, we can certainly meet up virtually.

I didn't get my new watch charged in time for today's run, but look for ongoing Nike+ updates here and via Facebook and Nike+ starting tomorrow!

(What's that you say? You haven't yet friended me on Facebook or Google+? Get with the program!)

Faithless

I have officially lost faith in modern medicine's ability to treat me as a type 1 diabetic.

Let me start by saying that I am a model diabetes patient. I eat a low-carbohydrate, low-fat diet consisting predominantly of foods with a very low glycemic index. I count my carbohydrates and administer my insulin doses correctly. I work out twice a day, occasionally supplementing those workouts with two 15-minute walks at mid-morning and mid-afternoon. I consistently go to bed between 10:00pm and 10:30pm, and consistently wake up between 5:00am and 5:30am. There is little variation in my routine. I consider myself to be a very easy-going guy who lives a low-stress lifestyle. I don't do drugs of any kind, and my alcohol consumption is extremely limited.

Nevertheless, I experience strange, inexplicable blood sugar swings from time-to-time.

The current treatment paradigm (if my experience with doctors and endocrinologists is anything by which to gauge) consists of an absurd practice of circular reasoning.

This begins as soon as one sits down to speak with one's physician. First, the doctor asks you how you're feeling and how your blood sugar has been. Regardless of the answer you give, the doctor responds by saying, "Well, let's see your numbers." (I don't mind a little small talk to break the ice, but the standards of a good bedside manner would suggest that the doctor not completely contradict the patient's response a matter of pure segue.)

From here, a couple of things might occur: 

Possibility One
If you, the patient, have had some sort of odd blood sugar event recently that you might want to discuss with an educated professional, you might say, "I had a really strange bout of high blood sugar last week that I'd like to discuss with you." To this, the doctor invariably responds by looking at your blood sugar readings and crafting a narrative around the numbers without ever actually listening to the patient's narrative of his/her own experience. 

The doctor will say, "High blood sugar? Did you count your carbs correctly? Did you take enough insulin? Have you been under stress? Are you sick?"

Of course, if it were that obvious, then the "bout of high blood sugar" would never have been deemed "really strange" by the patient in the first place! But at this point, the course of the interview has been set. At this point, the doctor will ask a couple of questions that will be patently impossible for the patient to answer, something along the lines of "What did you have for a snack six hours before you went high?" Or perhaps, "Do you know anyone who has been sick lately?"

The point of these questions is to provide some sort of prognosis without having to do any work. The point is to cross-examine the patient verbally until there is enough doubt or the memory is sufficiently fuzzy that the doctor can simply hazard an irrelevant guess that the patient is unable to falsify.

For the doctor, the problem is now solved. "Maybe" the patient did something wrong. Next.

Possibility Two
If you are persistent enough and keep good enough records, you can sometimes puncture this absurd rhetorical loop, cover all your bases, and present the doctor with your blood sugar event as it truly exists: a mystery to you. "Nope, doc, I did everything right this time. It's a total mystery."

Here, the physician will tell you that diabetes is a complex disorder with a lot of variables; that sometimes you do everything right and you just miss something somewhere, but that if you just keep trying, you will be able to attain blood glucose control. Then he/she will hand you a set of pamphlets and offer to schedule an appointment with a dietitian or diabetes educator.

Whatever else you can call this "prognosis," it is not much help. Call me crazy, but when I walk into a clinic with a medical question, I expect to receive some medical insight, not a bunch of easy answers or an official checklist to which we must all conform.

What I mean is, that's not medicine. It's not medical treatment. It's not health care. It's just a couple of stock responses to hard, pressing questions. If a doctor is not prepared to provide me with real answers, I would at least appreciate not being lied to, dismissed, and/or made to feel like I am in some way responsible for my blood glucose "shortcomings."

Here's What I Expect
If I ask my doctor why something strange might have happened, I expect a dialogue. I expect the doctor to ask a thorough set of questions about the experience, to take a couple of moments of brief reflection and to venture a guess. 

If the guess seems unsatisfactory to me, I expect the doctor to actually, openly admit that he or she does not actually have an explanation for what happened.

From there, I expect the doctor to send me along with a helpful suggestion or two and then here's the important part...

I expect the doctor to tell me that he or she will look into the issue, read up on it, ask his or her colleagues, and get back to me next time about what the most likely explanation is in his or her professional opinion.

But That Doesn't Happen
It might be a tall order, but on the other hand, when I'm at work and a client asks me a tough question, it is considered highly unprofessional to feed them a line of crap just to shut them up and then go about my day as usual. It is furthermore considered highly insufficient to just say, "I don't know, these things can be complex," and then not follow up with my client later on.

So I am not holding doctors to an absurd, unreasonable standard here. I am simply expecting health care practitioners to adhere to the same professional standards that we all do. And we all do. All of us except doctors.

The point is not that "all doctors are crap," but rather that I find it equally unreasonable for a doctor to treat me this way as I would if a plumber or a car salesman treated me this way. My standard here is universal.

Finally, if you plan on saying, "I have a good doctor, you just have to find the right one," please save your breath. I understand full well that there are good doctors out there. What I do not understand is why there are so few that adhere to the basic principles of professionalism. It shouldn't be so difficult to find doctors who are capable of the bare minimum. I'm not looking for excellence, I'm looking for competency.

And because I see so little of it among health care practitioners, I have concluded that as a group they cannot treat my diabetes. I am better off educating myself and using doctors for what they apparently only want to be used for: To write prescriptions and cite things out of the Therapeutic Guidelines book.

For all needs beyond that, you are better off educating yourself.

2012-03-22

Whitney Houston

I could really indulge myself here in what has become one of my favorite topics to explore: The slow, self-induced, actual-and-symbolic suicide of drug use.

The sad thing about Whitney Houston, though, is that it's all been said. For the majority of my lifetime, Whitney has been on a quest to do herself in. Reports now indicate that Houston's cause of death was some sort of combination of accidental drowning and cocaine use. We can all imagine how that must have occurred; there are really two possibilities. One is a self-induced heart attack that sent her under water, and the alternative is that she was so out-of-it that when her head slipped under, she didn't have the means to come back up for air.

It's been said that cocaine is a glamorous drug. Well, there you have it.

Life is a precious gift that many of us waste on symbolic suicide, sad thoughts, wistful dreaming, or a wanton disregard for anything other than the next few hours. I call this line of thought an excessively short cognitive time horizon. That is, the scope of one's decisions never elongates to the point where the full issue comes into cognitive focus. The hopeless despair of depression is in some ways an unfortunate inability to see far enough behind oneself to understand that pessimism could have brought us here, and will be the cause of our next bout of sorrow. The mindless self-indulgence of live-for-today partying is a failure to capture the much greater future gains of a more sentient lifestyle. And so on...

The good news is that things can be turned around just as easily. Even a major panic attack has a light at the end of the tunnel if you can gain enough focus on the fact that it is a physical sensation with an eventual end. Elongating your cognitive time-horizon is precisely how we rise above many of our problems, sorrows, and shortcomings and forge a brighter future.

To accomplish this, we often have to sit alone for a while and really contemplate the things that got us where we are (good and bad) and the things that will get us to the next junction on the interstate. The more foresight, the more hindsight, the better you understand your situation. That makes you better off.

It's a shame that promising, talented people can fall into the little traps that easily ensnare we of more modest backgrounds. On the other hand, if we can rise above, perhaps that means we have more promise and talent than we were giving ourselves credit for having.

Problem: Solution

Let's get Phase Two kicked off with a bang, shall we.

Anyone with type 1 diabetes knows the frustrations of dealing with health care practitioners who are patently uninformed when it comes to our condition. In some cases, these situations can be quite dangerous for us. We go to doctors, nurses, and so forth for help; if we instead receive bad advice then we are subsequently worse-off than we were when we came to them in the first place.

The Problem
Generalized, the problem seems to be that the supply of health care practitioners with even an elementary knowledge of diabetes is horrendously insufficient for the needs of diabetics in general. As with all medical supply insufficiencies, this is caused by over-regulation.

Shall I prove it? I could, but as I indicated yesterday, I no longer believe any human being anywhere is actually interested in the evidence of the matter.

At any rate, what matters is the cold, hard fact that all health care is under-supplied, and that we therefore confront the downstream effects of this. We live in a fettered, un-free health care market. Unless you plan on investing yourself in some "community organizing," casual drug use, government-subsidized employment, and then eventually seeking public office, your opinion is not going to count much when it comes to the supply of health care. Nor is mine.

Period. End of story. Now we deal with it.

The Solution
If you have diabetes - or any other serious illness - my conclusion is that you cannot sit idly by, placing your future in the hands of people who have no clue about your condition. You have to take the reins. You have to educate yourself to the point where it is almost impossible to meet someone who knows more about your condition than you do.

Why? Because you might find yourself in situations where the doctors' advice can literally put you at risk. If they don't know their stuff, they can do more harm than good.

We can bemoan the inadequacies of the world around us, or we can take them as they are: Wholly imperfect and not at all what we deserve.

Once we accept that we are neither getting a fair shake nor even a passable level of care, we gain precious freedom! This is the freedom to understand our situation, which then enables us to plan for it.

Knowing that I will likely never get the kind of health care I need, I have to take up the slack. I have to educate myself to the point that I can self-treat if it were required of me. Then, I have to be able to push back against some of the medical advice I get, including knowing when to just shut up and not contest the diagnoses/prognoses; then go do the right thing anyway.

Accepting the problem as-is is liberating precisely because it defines the situation in such a way that it can be dealt with. Solutions only present themselves when we acknowledge the realities of the problem and go forth from there.

Look for more Problem: Solution posts on the blog in the future.

2012-03-21

End Phase One: Begin Phase Two

Today, I'd like to briefly summarize why I do not see any hope for society or politics, and why I think we are headed for a new Dark Ages. Then, I'd like to shift gears and explain how Stationary Waves is going to change in light of my new-found revelations.

The Intellectual Apocalypse
Stanley Fish says:
I know the objections to what I have said here. It amounts to an apology for identity politics. It elevates tribal obligations over the universal obligations we owe to each other as citizens. It licenses differential and discriminatory treatment on the basis of contested points of view. It substitutes for the rule “don’t do it to them if you don’t want it done to you” the rule “be sure to do it to them first and more effectively.” It implies finally that might makes right. I can live with that.
David Henderson says:
In other words, Fish is not saying that you should judge the various speakers by whether their particular statements at hand are good and true. Rather, you should judge the speakers by whether what they say more generally is good and true. In other words, Fish sees Limbaugh's use of the words "slut" and "prostitute" as excuses to bash Limbaugh when he, Fish, would have wanted to bash him anyway even if he hadn't said those things. But because Fish would have no general desire to bash Schultz or Maher, he shouldn't bash them for saying vile things. 
I see why Fish ended the article with the final paragraph that I quoted at the top of this post. Those are exactly the consequences of his argument. Professor Fish may be able to "live with" the idea that "might makes right." I would suggest to him, though, that throughout history the idea that might makes right has caused many people to die. 
Finally, a commenter at Henderson's blog going by the moniker "Tom West" makes the following statements (emphases mine - and editorial note, I have excerpted and rearranged Mr. West's statements to convey his message as I have interpreted it; therefore, for an absolutely accurate account of what he said, I encourage you to visit the relevant post at EconLog.):
I would like to point out that given the absolute certainty of finding the same bad behavior on "your" side as on the "other" side (both sides being inhabited by human beings), to stand by one's principles and denounce both sides is essentially to cripple your own preferred side (especially given that your opponent is not going to extend the same courtesy to you). [1]
I use to fairly harshly condemn my own side for not living up to the highest standards, after all, "we're the good guys". As I get older, it no longer becomes so obvious that this is the "right" thing to do. Perhaps the cost of demanding enforcement of those principles is that my agenda never gets enacted at all? [2]
In other words, are you willing to betray the greater good to satisfy your principles? [1]
And in the apocalyptic visions of today, where being out of power for 4-8 years leads to the inevitable destruction of the country, if not the world, every battle has become too important to cede for principle's sake. [3]
 I have to say, in Mr. West's defense, his point of view appears to me to be the prevailing opinion in the world. That is to say, I think West has assessed the situation accurately.

Unfortunately, I think this means that the dialogue is so poisoned that there is no hope of producing anything from it. If the dialogue consists of little more than lies, then the dialogue itself is a liar's game only.

I'm not a liar. I won't play the game. My principles matter.

Where Do We Go From Here?
When every discussion is little more than a game to see who can trick the broader public into believing a falsehood, when evidence is of no merit in an ideological discussion, when people are more interested in maintaining untenable beliefs than in living their lives in accordance with the truth, then life takes on a much different flavor.

I am assessing reality as I see it. Politics ends in war. Truth is a matter for ideologues to bandy over. The only thing that seems to matter is the lynch mob, and who they have in their sights.

Therefore, it strikes me as a little silly to write blog articles analyzing logic, evidence, and theory, uncovering truth, and presenting it to the public at large. In doing so, I would be setting myself up. In doing so, I would be presenting something that I know to be true, but which will only be interpreted as a political proposition.

In a word, in submitting my truth the political arena, I undermine it by making it look like a matter of opinion.

No thanks.

Life is about being the best you can be. That much is certain, no matter how cheesy it might sound. So, rather than using my blog to uncover new evidence and demonstrate universal truths, I think from now on I will invest more time in exploring how to preserve what little knowledge, truth, dignity, and morality we have left.

Given the climate of "debate" out there, I think it far more useful to explore how the truth can be preserved by those who still value its existence. There is a future for humanity, no matter how it looks. If society seems uninterested in becoming freer and more ethical, perhaps our children will be far less hostile to such things. In the meantime, we have to cling to the truth to avoid getting lost in the muck.

Stationary Waves, therefore, will henceforth be more of an exploration of how to live free in an unfree world; and less an exploration of freedom itself. Life is not perfect. From now on, I'd like to invest myself in determining how to make the most of it.

2012-03-20

Custom Coaching

If you'd like to know what a Stationary Waves beginner's running workout plan looks like, saunter on over to the always-fabulous iluvtoeat.blogspot.com for a look at Week 1 of a tailor-made 5K training plan.

Interested in having your own workout plan designed especially for you? Contact me to begin the process.

2012-03-19

Chinese Shock?

Last week, I blogged about what I considered to be a sign of Chinese real estate price inflation, or a real estate bubble, depending on how you look at it.

Today, with a hat tip to Marginal Revolution, we see further evidence, only this time in the form of a 20% market contraction.

This certainly doesn't bode well for China and cannot at all bode well for the global marketplace. My biggest fear, however, is not that the markets will crash, but that a market crash will herald a Chinese return to a command economy. The West has seen these boom-and-bust cycles before. China has, too, but never under the auspices of a free market economy.